24 February, 2024

Railways that are on the verge of permanent closure

As this blog described before, the Japanese Government and railway companies have been discussing about the fate of rural railways that run sparsely populated areas. Most of such railways were constructed before the Second World War, mainly for freight trains transporting coal or wood. They were designed for light freight trains running at slow speed so that they became outdated after the War. Hence, the central and local governments constructed well-maintained roads that connect towns and villages far shorter than those railways. As a result, they have not been used by local residents for nearly or even more than half a century.

On Tuesday 13 February 2024, I visited two railways in western Japan that are placed on top of the "endangered railways" list: Geibi and Kisuki lines. They are two least used railways that JR West has been operating. Here is what I thought about them with a few photos.


Geibi line

Geibi line is a 160 km (100 miles) long railway that connects Bitchu-Kojiro station in Okayama Prefecture and Hiroshima station. The line from Hiroshima to Shimo-Fukawa has been heavily used by commuters and students, while that between Bingo-Ochiai and Tojo is miserable as there are less than 20 passengers a day. According to statistics, it costs approximately 25,000 yen to earn a revenue of 100 yen there.


The line starts from Bitchu-Kojiro, but all services are extended to Niimi station, which is close to the city centre. Niimi is an interchange station with two more lines available: Hakubi line towards Okayama or Yonago (de facto main line) and Kishin line towards Tsuyama (another rural railway). There are six Geibi line services but three of them terminate at Tojo, so there are only three trains a day between Tojo and Bingo-Ochiai.


The service 443D to Bingo-Ochiai departed Niimi at 1 pm with just five passengers in total: three railway enthusiasts including me, a high-school girl and an elderly woman. The latter two alighted from the train within 20 minutes, and another elderly man came in to the train and left at Tojo. The train ran in the middle of nowhere with no other local resident onboard.


Rural railways in western Japan are sluggish as JR West has imposed extremely slow speed limits on curves, tunnels and bridges. They were due to minimise the maintenance cost, and the 25 km/h (15.5 mph) restrictions are lowered to 15 km/h (9 mph) when raining or snowing. However, even if there had been no such limits, trains would not have been fast enough to win a race against cars.


The train entered into Hiroshima Prefecture just before arriving at Tojo station, which is one of few major stations but only has eight users per day. I must say that I could not find anything particularly interesting there, but there was one thing that attracted me 20 minutes later at Uchina station. It seemed that a volunteer sometimes decorated the station with lovely flowers on the pole. It was said to be "heavily" used by local residents back in the 1980s…though merely around 10 people a day then.


The train arrived at Bingo-Ochiai, probably the least busiest interchange station in Japan. All Geibi line services in this area start from or terminate at here so that all passengers have to change trains. Kisuki line also branches off. It was once a bustling station as steam trains had to be refilled. According to a pamphlet, there were restaurants and even a ski resort near the station. It sharply declined when all steam trains were replaced with diesel ones in 1971, and there are only a handful buildings in the area today.


Kisuki line

Kisuki line is 82 km (51 miles) long and connects Bingo-Ochiai and Shinji. Actual distance between these stations is less than 48 km (30 miles), but the railway is longer than that as it locates in and between mountains. In spite of lengthy route and low speed, the line was served by a few express services that connected Hiroshima and Matsue until 1990, but they were completely superseded by buses on a motorway. There were only four passengers including me when the service 1462D left Bingo-Ochiai, and all of them must be railway enthusiasts. Probably it was the busiest among just three services on that day.


As soon as the train left Bingo-Ochiai, phone signals went out. The train ran slowly so that it took more than 10 minutes between stations. There was "Okuizumo Orochi Loop" between Miinohara and Izumo-Sakane. The National Route 314 has such a spiral loop to climb a mountain, while Kisuki line goes further east to do so. Cars were running at 60 km/h (obviously exceeding the speed limit) while the train ran at 25 km/h.


Kisuki line is often closed in winter. Not only Hokkaido and Tohoku region but also part of Chugoku region is prone to heavy snow. Fortunately, there was little snow as it was warmer than usual, but warm temperature in winter sometimes causes another problem: avalanche.


Kisuki line has a zig zag near Izumo-Sakane station. The train reversed twice before arriving at the station so that it took 17 minutes from Miinohara. As mentioned above, smartphones are mostly "no service" in the area so that anyone visiting the line should download a map in advance.


Approaching Izumo-Sakane. There is a spring next to a station building and it is called "water of longevity" (延命水, enmei sui). There is a myth that a racoon dog that lived for more than 100 years loved this water. It has been certified by the authorities and anyone can drink it, but I could not do so as the train stopped only for three minutes.


The train reached to the civilisation. Kisuki is the largest intermediate station on the line that locates near the city centre of Unnan. There are vending machines and a supermarket in front of the station. There are 11 services a day towards Shinji, so it now sounds like a normal rural railway. There were around 15 passengers in total as the train went towards Shinji, where the train terminated.


The three-hour journey on Kisuki line finally came to an end. All passengers including me looked for San'in line service to Yonago, which departed shortly after the Kisuki line train's arrival. Even with extremely small number of service, it was not difficult to make a trip as train connections were good.


Personal views

I enjoyed the trip, but I also found neither lines could survive. There were only a handful of passengers on both trains, all of which were railway enthusiasts. There was literally no local resident near Bingo-Ochiai station, and it clearly shows that the railways have already fulfilled its role decades ago.

Many people blame ageing society and depopulation for the permanent closure of rural railways, but it is not always correct. Even with lots of young people, the railway would not have been used as those railways are far longer than roads. The railways were constructed when civil engineering was not developed enough, while roads were constructed with the latest technology. These railways are simply obsolete and susceptible to natural disaster, and I must concede that nothing can justify these railways. Safety, reliability, speed, comfortability and eco-friendliness…road transportation prevails the railways in all terms.

Some activists may argue that trains are always greener than cars, but it is simply wrong. Maintaining those railways require far more budget, resources and energy than keeping roads nearby available. Buses and taxi services will certainly be far more beneficial than trains for people living in this area. As elderly people have been struggling to drive a car, local governments should concentrate on alternative transports and delivery services as soon as possible rather than sticking to railways that no one uses.


Itinerary

The table below shows how did the journey go on. I stayed at a hotel in Yonago so that my entire trip was like a large circle. I had another business in Neu, so ignore the first two lines.

 Yonago  ( 6:08)  Neu  ( 6:33) 
 Neu  (11:53)  Niimi  (12:35) 
 Niimi  (13:02)  Bingo-Ochiai  (14:28) 
 Bingo-Ochiai  (14:43)  Shinji  (17:38) 
 Shinji  (17:44)  Yonago  (18:41) 

Those who plan to do a similar trip should carefully check timetables as some services do not run on certain days due to planned engineering work. It is also highly recommended to buy sufficient amount of water and food before getting on a train (there are two convenience stores near Niimi station). There is no need to worry about a toilet as the rolling stock on these lines has one.

10 February, 2024

Tokyu Q Seat, the empty express

"Q Seat" is a service that has been provided by Tokyu since 2018. It is a seat reservation scheme during evening rush hour for commuters fed up with extremely packed trains. It was first introduced to Oimachi and Den-en-toshi lines, and there are nine Express services leaving Oimachi station between 5:00 pm and 9:40 pm on weekdays. Each service is formed of seven coaches, and one of them is designated as Q Seat that requires a 500-yen additional fare. Since Den-en-toshi line has been infamous for congestion, many passengers choose the all-reserved coach on the way home for up to 40 minutes.


* The seats will be turned to transverse ones when used in the evening

In August 2023, Tokyu introduced the scheme to Toyoko line with the same price. Two out of ten coaches of express services leaving Shibuya between 7:35 pm and 9:35 pm (precisely every 30 minutes) are Q Seat. As Q Seat is designed for commuters living near Tokyu stations, the trains have to stop at more stations than the fastest limited express services.

However, Toyoko line Q Seat has obviously been unsuccessful. The company must have imagined that the ridership would be as good as those on Oimachi and Den-en-toshi line, but there are only a handful passengers per Q Seat coach.


Tokyu has been desperate to promote the Q Seat on Toyoko line. It has offered a 50% off deal from 13 November to 29 December and again from 9 to 31 January. Furthermore, a bottle of green tea or yoghurt-based beverage (which roughly cost 160 yen) will be given without charge from 5 to 29 February. Despite these efforts, Toyoko line users seem to believe that it is not reasonable or useful enough.

Why Toyoko line Q Seat suffers from low ridership?

The start of the services

All Q Seat trains start from Shibuya station, but not a few Toyoko line passengers commute to even farther such as Shinjuku and Ikebukuro. They use direct services towards Shinjuku and Ikebukuro in the morning, but they have to alight a train at Shibuya if they wish to use Q Seat in the evening. This is simply inconvenient, and it must be the main reason for low usage.

Rivals

Unlike Den-en-toshi line, Toyoko line has a major competitor: Shonan-Shinjuku line. Both lines run between Shibuya and Yokohama and call at Musashi-Kosugi. JR East's Green Car is more expensive than Q Seat, but given the extensive network, JR can be more convenient than Q Seat trains.

Speed and duration

Unlike similar services that other train operators provide, Toyoko's Q Seat is not the fastest service of the line as mentioned above. Express trains on Toyoko line is notorious for stopping too many stations, calling at 14 out of 26 stations (excluding Shibuya). This is simply too slow, but Tokyu might have been in a dilemma: if Q Seat had been available on limited express services, even fewer people would use it as it only calls at major interchange stations and thus lose in battle against JR.

What is worse, exhausted commuters do not necessarily have to rely on Q Seat to secure a seat. There are "local" services calling at all stations start from Shibuya roughly every 10 minutes. A table below shows how different their duration from Shibuya is.

Express Local 
 Den-en-chofu  13 mins  17 mins 
 Tamagawa  15 mins  19 mins 
 Musashi-kosugi  17 mins  22 mins 
 Hiyoshi  21 mins  27 mins 
 Tsunashima  23 mins  29 mins 
 Kikuna  27 mins  34 mins 
 Yokohama  33 mins  48 mins 

Local trains take more than express trains, but the differences are not significant. When everyone has a chance to have a seat on the local train, how many people think of paying 500 yen more?

To make the service more attractive, Tokyu has to do something other than providing a bottle. First, Q Seat should start from Fukutoshin line stations such as Ikebukuro and Shinjuku-sanchome. However, it must be a hard work for Tokyu as it has to negotiate with Tokyo Metro. Tokyo Metro has already had similar services (namely Odakyu Romancecar on Chiyoda line and TH Liner on Hibiya line), and it will certainly apply a similar fare. Thus, the Q Seat ticket is likely to be around 710 yen, which would be too expensive.

Second, Tokyu should consider providing the service during morning rush hour as well. Generally speaking, train congestion is worse in the morning than in the evening so that there might be a demand for seat reservation.

Third, Tokyu should also consider providing the service at the weekend. Parents with infants or babies and elderly people have struggled with packed trains on Saturday and Sunday. It might be a good promotion of Q Seat, and some of the parents may use it on weekdays as well.

The aforementioned options must have been on table, and the company will hopefully sort the problem out. Otherwise, the brand new Q Seat coaches would just be a waste of money.

23 January, 2024

A major incident on the high-speed rail in Japan

At around 10 am on Tuesday 23 January, a damage to overhead wires have been detected between Omiya and Ueno stations (near Kita-Yono station on Saikyo line). According to Nikkei, loose electric wires damaged a train to Tokyo. JR East announced that there would be no service on Tohoku Shinkansen (between Tokyo and Sendai), Joetsu and Hokuriku Shinkansen (between Tokyo and Takasaki) today with severe delays on the rest of the network.

What is worse, it is reported that two staff have been sent to hospital as they got a shock and were in flames. One of them is seriously injured while the other suffers from minor injuries. It indicates that power had not been cut during the work, which could be a material breach of safety procedures.

Japanese railway has been hailed everywhere as the safest and the most reliable in the world, but JR East has been accused of ill-management with lack of will to observe safety requirements. As Toyo Keizai reported, there have been many cases which could have been deadly accidents since the 2010s, including a major fire at a substation that halted Takasaki line for three days, a pole collapsing on Yamanote line and a Keihin-Tohoku line train colliding with a maintenance vehicle at Kawasaki station. In all cases, the Transportation Bureau (a part of the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism) concluded that those incidents would not have happened if JR East had exercised normal precautions. Nevertheless, the company has not taken appropriate measures so that it has failed to prevent similar cases. Last year, the Transportation Bureau issued a warning concerning an accident near Ofuna station in which passengers and crew were injured after a train collided with poles. The document starts with "In spite of repeated warnings concerning safety and reliability, the Bureau profoundly regrets that…", which clearly indicates that the authorities have been frustrated with a negligent attitude of the train operator.

Nevertheless, it was revealed that the company is incapable of reviewing safety as managers and executive members seem to be more interested in other businesses than railway. Bunshun reported earlier this year that Yoichi Kise, the vice president of JR East, forced his subordinates to have excessive amount of Shaoxing wine (traditional Chinese wine), ending up in alcohol poisoning which required ambulance service to intervene. It seems that they cannot secure safety even in their "private" life.

Trains in Japan are generally safe, probably one of the safest in the world. There have been no fatal high-speed train accidents involving operation of the trains since its history began in 1964. However, JR East now lacks the capability to keep its staff safe, and this incident is a stark warning to the future of the company. Unless every member of the company recognises the seriousness of the case and take any necessary measures, passengers will surely be in grave danger.

13 January, 2024

The Red List of Trains in Japan (Jan-2024 update)

The Red List of Trains in Japan has been updated. The list of JR trains has rearranged so that it might be less confusing than before.

There are only two new articles: Yokohama Seaside Line 1000 series and 2000 series, but more than 200 articles now have the latest figures, some of which resulted in a status change as the number declined.

01 January, 2024

New Year Greetings 2024

The year 2024 has begun. I wish all of you lots of luck and happiness.
Here are my commitments to this blog, my website and social media.


About this blog

I planned closure of this blog once last year due to significantly low number of visitors. However, the trend has slightly changed in the last few months, and approximately 9.63k views have been recorded in 2023 (approximately 24.8 views a day). It is obviously not a large number, but it has exceeded my anticipation. Therefore, I have decided to continue updating this blog this year, and I endeavour to post new a new article on second and fourth Saturdays every month. However, it might not go as scheduled when I am busy. Check my social media accounts for latest updates.


About The Red List of Trains in Japan

The Red List of Trains in Japan will be slightly redesigned later this month, and its lists may look a little different. The website will be updated once every 2-3 months. I also have a plan to write articles about "fun facts", but I will probably post them to this blog rather than the website.


About the use of social media

As X has been getting more and more unreliable these days, I have decided to use it even less than last year. Instead of the former Twitter, I will use Mastodon, Bluesky and Threads more often than ever. I recommend everyone having an account on different social media platforms. Feel free to ask me any question related to railways in Japan or other general topics using those platforms.