General information

23 December, 2023

Looking back this year (2023)

Christmas has not even arrived yet, and there is still more than a week before the year 2023 ends. Nevertheless, I would like to look back this year with my four favourite photos I took.


Spring

Kotoden 1300 series running between Takata and Ikenobe stations on Kotoden Nagao Line, Kagawa Prefecture. This rolling stock was originally designed and used by Keikyu so that a group of enthusiasts restored it to the original livery in the previous year.


Summer

Keikyu N1000 series (variant 1800) approaching Rokugodote station on Keikyu Main Line. It was the first time for the 1800 subseries to run for a regular passenger train whilst having gangway connection equipment in the middle of its front end. Such a feature itself is extremely rare these days.


Autumn

Jomo 100 series, the oldest operational train in Japan (excluding trams) ran on the entire Jomo Line. This train was built in 1928 and it is sometimes used for rail tours in Gunma Prefecture, 60 miles north of Tokyo.


Winter

JNR 381 series running between Kurosaka and Neu stations on Hakubi Line, Tottori Prefecture. It is the only train with the iconic "National Railways Limited Express Livery". JR West plans to withdraw all 381 series trains by June 2024.


So, this is the last update of the year. I would like to thank everyone who visited my blog this year. The next article will be published on the New Year's Day. Also check other photos I took this year on my Japanese blog.

16 December, 2023

2024 Timetable Changes on JR Network

JR companies published details about timetable revision on Saturday 16th March 2024. Unlike the past three years, several lines will provide more services than before, indicating the end of train reduction caused by COVID-19 pandemic. The revision usually takes place once a year, and what happens next time?


Reservation Scheme

Before looking into each company, it is important to note about limited express trains. After the timetable change, limited express services listed below will have reserved seats only.

 Hokkaido: Hokuto, Ozora, Suzuran, Tokachi
 East: Sazanami, Shiosai, Wakashio
 Central: Shirasagi
 West: Thunderbird, Super Hakuto
Super Inaba, Yakumo

According to the companies, introducing the all-reserved scheme will be fair for all passengers as they no longer have to wait for hours at platform to have a seat. Moreover, reserved-seat tickets are a little more expensive than non-reserved tickets so that the companies can expect more revenue. Furthermore, conductors will no longer have to carry out ticket inspection for all passengers onboard, but just have to check a tablet and only ask those sitting on a unreserved seat for ticket.


JR Hokkaido

JR Hokkaido has been declining for years because of financial difficulties, but there is good news. As ridership increased (thanks to foreign travellers), more Rapid Airport services will be provided. There are going to be six trains per hour instead of five between New Chitose Airport and Sapporo at daytime, one of which will be "Special Rapid" calling fewer stations than before (Sapporo, Shin-Sapporo, Mimani-Chitose and the Airport).

On the other hand, five stations on rural lines such as Soya Main Line will be closed. Furthermore, Nemuro Main Line between Furano and Shintoku, most of which has been closed since 2016 due to a devastating typhoon, will be permanently closed on 31st March. The company has been downsizing its network in scarcely populated areas including stations with less than a single user per week. This trend is, as everyone anticipated, continues.


JR East

A brand new E8 series bullet train enters into Yamagata Shinkansen service, replacing E3 series. The new E8 series can run at up to 300 km/h (187 mph), but its maximum speed will be restricted to 275 km/h (171 mph) until all E3 series retire in 2025 or 2026.

Furthermore, ten Yamabiko services on Tohoku Shinkansen at the daytime, which have been reduced since the pandemic began, will be reinstated.


Some E259 series will be reallocated to Limited Express Shiosai (Tokyo – Choshi), replacing all 255 series trains. The Narita Express trains have been repainted since earlier this year, suggesting that they will also be used for other trains.


205 series on Tsurumi Line retires. The commuter train introduced by Japanese National Railways is due to be superseded by brand new E131 series from Christmas Eve, and all old trains will be withdrawn by 16 March.


JR Central

All smoking rooms on Tokaido Shinkansen trains will be closed. Drinking water bottles will be stored in the room and will be provided in case of emergency.

In other news, all services on Chuo Main Line between Nagoya and Nakatsugawa (except Limited Expres Shinano) will be provided by brand new 315 series trains, with maximum speed being raised from 110 to 130 km/h (81 mph).


JR West

Hokuriku Shinkansen, one of the high-speed rails in Japan, will be extended from Kanazawa to Tsuruga in Fukui Prefecture. The fastest service between Tokyo and Tsuruga will take 3 hours and 8 minutes, 50 minutes shorter than the current timetables. 14 services run between Tokyo and Tsuruga every day and more during peak seasons.


Limited express services on Hokuriku Main Line will be rearranged as Shinkansen is extended. To put it simply, those trains between Kanazawa and Tsuruga will be replaced with the Hokuriku Shinkansen. Hence, Thunderbird will run between Osaka and Tsuruga, and Shirasagi will run between Nagoya and Tsuruga. Those who travel from Osaka or Nagoya to Kanazawa and vice versa will also benefit from the new high-speed rail in terms of journey time, but not in terms of fares.

681 series is expected to sharply decline as redundant 683 series will be reallocated to Shirasagi.


There will be new Limited Express Raku Raku Yamato between Nara and Shin-Osaka via Kansai Main Line and Osaka Loop Line. It is specifically designed for commuters who want to have a seat. There will be one return journey a day (weekdays only): one for Shin-Osaka in the morning and the other for Nara in the evening. The entire journey takes 66 minutes. The company also extends Limited Express Raku Raku Harima as such services have been successful. Furthermore, seat reservation scheme on Osaka Higashi Line and Yamatoji Line services during rush hours will be expanded.


To ease congestion amid growing number of foreign tourists, there will be more San-in Main Line (Sagano Line) services between Kyoto and Saga-Arashiyama. This line has been infamous for being overcrowded and yet JR West had been reluctant to do something. It seems that the company finally decided to provide more trains.


273 series, the brand new train for Limited Express Yakumo, will enter into service on 6th April (NOT 16 March). 381 series, the 40-year-old iconic train, will retire by June 2024.


JR Shikoku and JR Kyushu

There is no major changes on their timetables, but JR Shikoku will even out schedules of rural lines. For example, regional services on Kotoku Line at the daytime will leave Takamatsu station 42 minutes past the hour. Tokushima Line trains will leave Tokushima station 22 and 52 minutes past the hour. JR companies have long been accused of providing regional trains in rural areas uneven and thus hard to remember, but such improvement will surely be welcomed by local residents.

There is a rumour that 713 series trains in Miyazaki will retire on the day, but JR Kyushu has not mentioned about its fate so far.




There have been sad news about railways in Japan in the last three years, but it is good to hear that there are several positive aspects. Note that abovementioned information is merely a summary of documents published by six JR companies. For detail, check official press release as listed below.

09 December, 2023

115 series, a weird suburban train

This is 115 series, a suburban train developed in the early-1960s by Japanese National Railways. It is still common in Okayama, roughly 350 miles west of Tokyo. The 115 series had been used across the country until the late-2010s, but most of them retired. Okayama is one of a few places where old trains are operational even today.


Okayama has been well-known among trainspotters in these days for having iconic trains, and the traditional design usually makes Japanese railway enthusiasts feeling nostalgic...but this 115 series look totally different to the original style. Its front end is frankly ugly and apparently cheap. What on earth is this?


This is so-called G units in Okayama. There are eight two-carriage units in total, and each unit is formed of two coaches: KuMoHa 115 variant 1500 (south/east) and KuMoHa 114 variant 1000 (north/west). The front coach on the south/east side looks normal, as JNR welded a new drivers cab and an intermediate carriage together to make a KuMoHa 115-1500s carriage. The construction took place in 1983-86.


On the other hand, KuMoHa 114-1000s does not look right. It was converted from another intermediate carriage by JR West in 2001. The company pursued the cheapest possible options to make short trains for rural lines consisted of two coaches. Hence, its design is far from what is supposed to be.

JR West had used various odd-looking trains converted from intermediate carriages in other areas until the mid-2010s, but they have already been withdrawn, and the G units in Okayama are the only ones remaining in service.


All G unit carriages were originally built in 1978-82, and so-called 40N Refurbishment has been carried out by JR West. They are compatible with driver-only operation, and now used for services on Ako Line (Banshu-Ako - Okayama), Hakubi Line (entire line), San-in Main Line (as far as Nishi-Izumo) and San-yo Main Line (Seto - Kurashiki via Okayama).

The 40N programme is designed to extend a lifespan of the train to around 40 years. All eight units have already exceeded it, but JR West is likely to use them for a while as they are suitable for unprofitable rural lines, and the company has been reluctant to invest in scarcely populated areas. Even so, a major change to their operation is likely to take place soon following the introduction of brand new 227 series trains.


The full formation list is as follows.
(Left: towards Banshu-Ako, Seto
Right: towards Yonago, Nishi-Izumo)

 Unit No.  KuMoHa 115  KuMoHa 114 
 G-01  1503  1098 
 G-02  1505  1102 
 G-03  1508  1117 
 G-04  1515  1173 
 G-05  1516  1178 
 G-06  1517  1194 
 G-07  1518  1196 
 G-08  1551  1118 

02 December, 2023

The Red List of Trains in Japan (Dec-2023 update)

The Red List of Trains in Japan has been updated with four new articles, namely:

This update contains more significant feature: lager fonts for smartphone version. I have been struggling with small letters on my smartphone screen but it took months to redress the issue. Now the website is easier for smartphone users to read (hopefully) with no major trouble

25 November, 2023

The steepest railway in Japan and autumn leaves

Unlike other past articles, this is a part of my diary though related to Japanese railways.

Yesterday, I went with a friend of mine to Mt Takao in Tokyo, roughly 30 miles west of Shinjuku station. Takao station is known for de facto terminal for Chuo Line (Rapid) commuter trains, but the mountain is a mile west of the station. Takaosanguchi station on Keio Takao line is the closest to the entrance of the mountain.


Mt Takao is best known for magnificent views in autumn, particularly tree leaves turning red. There is a funicular called Takaosan Cable Car, which starts from a station near Takaosanguchi. Trees have already been red, but this area is not high and cold enough so that the autumn foliage does not look impressive.


The funicular is the steepest railway in Japan with a 608 ‰ (60.8% or 1 in 1.645) slope. The line is just 0.63 miles long but climbs 889 ft. As the train climbs, the slope gets steeper. The train takes just six minutes but it was tough.


There are usually four trains per hour but they run every 10 minutes during busy period. Even so, I had to wait in a queue for 30-40 minutes. There were aerial lifts called Echo Lift near the funicular but the queue was even longer.


The other funicular station is just the halfway to the peak of the mountain. There are a small museum, botanical garden and a monkey zoo, temples and shrines, but the best place for the autumn leaves is further away, which takes an hour on foot.


Most tourists stop at the peak and turn back, but there is a great place called Momijidai that is about 10 minutes more.


There are several walking trails that go further, but they are not recommended to those who just plan to visit the mountain with T-shirt and sandals during a day-trip. Otherwise, you may eventually end up in a rescue helicopter.

Takaosanguchi station is less than an hour from Shinjuku station by Keio line trains. The funicular is crowded during the high season, and we were told to wait for 70-90 minutes on the way home (4 pm on Friday) so that we gave up getting on a train and walked down the mountain, taking roughly 30 minutes. The queue must be even longer on Saturdays and Sundays.

11 November, 2023

Farewell, Airport Express

On Saturday 25 November, annual timetable revision will be taken place on the entire Keikyu network. On this day, all Airport Express services will be renamed simply as Express. This article focuses on Airport Express on the southern part of Keikyu Main Line (i.e. to and from Zushi).

Keikyu introduced Airport Express when it dramatically revised its timetables on 16 May 2010. To meet demand for services between Haneda Airport and Yokohama, the company decided to provide a new service on the southern part of Keikyu Main Line. There had been Express services in the area until 1999, but they were completely different from Airport Express.


At first, Airport Express ran every 20 minutes, most of which were formed of eight coaches and connecting Haneda Airport and Shin-Zushi (now Zushi Hayama) stations. Railway enthusiasts welcomed the timetable revision as 2000 series returned to daytime services for the first time since 2002. Some people using small stations were dissatisfied with Airport Express as the number of stopping services was halved.


As Haneda Airport International Terminal station (now Terminal 3 station) opened in 2012 and ridership increased, Airport Express was doubled to every 10 minutes. There have been some six-car trains since then. The Airport Express was heavily used not only by businesspeople and tourists but also local residents such as those going to school or for shopping.


Literally all types of rolling stock have been used for Airport Express except one. 800 series could not enter Keikyu Airport Line as it was not compatible with platform edge doors at Haneda Airport International Terminal station. Hence, 800 series was used only between Kanagawa-Shimmachi and Shin-Zushi in case of severe service disruption and when there was absolutely no other option.


Airport Express suddenly suffered from low ridership in the 2020s. Just like all other businesses across the country and the world, the impact of COVID-19 pandemic was immense. As international travels to and from Japan had been restricted for two years, the ridership drastically dropped.

Furthermore, staff shortages triggered by poor working conditions amid inflation struck Airport Express: significant reduction of services was carried out last year and Airport Express became every 20 minutes again. Since many services have been consisted of six coaches, the capacity is smaller than back in 2010.


Then, the 13-year history of Airport Express ends on 24 November, a day before the timetable revision. After that day, Express services calling at the same stations will run, a few of which do not start from or terminate at Haneda Airport (that is why the company decided to remove the word Airport). The frequency remains unchanged (every 20 minutes) but it will surely be changed along with other services soon as Keikyu lacks will or capability to deal with pay rises and reduce overworking of station staff and train crews.

29 October, 2023

50 years on: a comparison (part 7)...Nagoya, Kansai and Fukuoka

As shown in the previous article, Japanese National Railways had provided long-distance trains calling at every station, but the number of stopping services per se was far fewer than today. Even in Tokyo, suburban trains like Tokaido and Tohoku Main Lines ran once or twice every hour in the afternoon. In other major cities, things had been worse than that.


Nagoya area

Nagoya has been the largest station in the area since the late-19th century, and Tokaido Main, Chuo Main and Kansai Main Lines have been serving the station. The first table shows westbound suburban trains on Tokaido Main Line departing Nagoya station between 9-11 am. All trains in 1973 and fast services in 2023 are for Ogaki, while Local trains in 2023 terminate at Gifu.

 1973  2023 
   9:07 Special Rapid  
   9:09 Local  
   9:18 Special Rapid  
   9:23 Local  
 9:30 Local   9:29 New Rapid  
   9:36 Rapid  
   9:41 Local  
   9:45 Special Rapid  
   9:50 Local  
 9:57 Rapid   10:00 New Rapid  
   10:05 Local  
   10:15 New Rapid   
   10:20 Local  
   10:35 Rapid  
 10:35 Local   10:35 Local  
   10:45 New Rapid   
   10:50 Local  

Here is another table showing eastbound Tokaido Main Line trains leaving Nagoya during evening rush hours, specifically between 5-7 pm. L means Local, N means New Rapid, R means Rapid and SR means Special Rapid.

 1973  2023 
   17:01 NR: Toyohashi 
 17:08 L: Hamamatsu  17:03 L: Toyohashi 
   17:16 SR: Toyohashi 
   17:18 L: Okazaki 
   17:31 SR: Toyohashi 
   17:33 L: Toyohashi 
 17:40 R: Shizuoka  17:46 SR: Toyohashi 
 17:48 L: Hamamatsu  17:48 L: Okazaki 
   18:00 NR: Toyohashi 
   18:02 L: Toyohashi 
   18:10 NR: Toyohashi 
 18:15 L: Toyohashi  18:17 L: Okazaki 
   18:20 SR: Toyohashi 
   18:30 NR: Toyohashi 
   18:33 L: Hamamatsu 
 18:40 R: Hamamatsu  18:40 SR: Toyohashi 
   18:47 L: Okazaki 
   18:50 SR: Toyohashi 

It was clear that JNR was not interested in commuters and students going to or back from their workplace or school. That is why, most people used Meitetsu that provided far more convenient services at that time. Tokaido Main Line eastbound services were even more useless at daytime with only a Local train per hour.

Chuo Main Line services were slightly better, with two trains departed Nagoya station at the daytime with four trains between 6-7 pm. Today, there are eight trains per hour at the daytime and more during rush hours.

Kansai Main Line was frankly awful, with only 13 trains a day in 1973. It is worth noting that two of them ran from Nagoya to Minatomachi (now JR Namba) and one from Nagoya to Tennoji via Kisei Main Line. Even so, it did not mean that the line was useful. Hence, most local residents must have relied on Kintetsu. Today, there are four trains per hour on Kansai Main Line at off-peak times.


Osaka area

JNR services in Osaka had been infamous for being inconvenient, but to be fair, JNR was not necessarily reluctant to compete with private railways. Special Rapid was introduced in 1970 with just six services per day, but there were four services per hour in 1973. There were also four rapid trains between Kusatsu and Nishi-Akashi (including Kyoto, Osaka and Sannomiya stations). Local trains ran every 15-30 minutes, half the number of what we see today.

However, other suburban trains were totally different at that time. The notable example is San-in Main Line, which is now also called Sagano Line. There are four trains per hour between Kyoto and Kameoka at off-peak times and up to seven during rush hours, but there were only 21 trains a day in 1973.

 5:20  Hamada 
 6:43  Tsuruga (via Ayabe) 
 7:50  Ayabe 
 8:27  Sonobe 
 9:06  Izumoshi 
 10:27  Sonobe 
 11:12  Fukuchiyama 
 12:30  Fukuchiyama 
 15:11  Goma 
 15:53  Fukuchiyama 
 16:57  Sonobe 
 17:19  Fukuchiyama 
 17:39  Sonobe 
 18:14  Fukuchiyama 
 18:53  Sonobe 
 19:27  Ayabe 
 20:28  Ayabe 
 21:04  Sonobe 
 21:42  Fukuchiyama 
 22:04  Izumoshi* 
 22:55  Sonobe 

The ridership of San-in Main Line was far smaller in 1973 than today as there were not so many houses. The line might not have been an option for tourists visiting Saga and Arashiyama area. Most trains were loco-hauled so that they were slower than trains of today. Interestingly, four out of 21 trains were long-distance (running more than three hours), and the 22:04 service had a sleeper coach. This train arrived Izumoshi at 9:31 on the following day.

The line was electrified in 1990 with a dramatic track improvement project finally completed in 2010. The modernisation programme made it far easier for local residents to go to Kyoto so that houses and blocks of flats were built near stations.


Fukuoka area

At Hakata in 1973, southbound suburban trains on Kagoshima Main Line included services to Amagase, Hita (both via Kyudai Main Line) and Yatsushiro, but ran every 60-90 minutes at the daytime and up to just three trains per hour at peak times (excluding Minami-Fukuoka services). Today, there are 5-6 trains per hour.

Northbound trains towards Kokura and Mojiko ran twice or three times per hour at daytime, while there are five today. Interestingly, there were Special Rapid services between Hakata and Kokura, calling only at Kurosaki and Tobata. The Special Rapid left Hakata 10 past every hour (9:10 – 19:10) and the fastest one took just 54 minutes from Hakata to Kokura. Today, the fastest train takes more than an hour so that busy businesspeople have to choose San-yo Shinkansen.

How about Sasaguri Line? Today, it is also known today as Fukuhoku-yutaka Line and there are 3-6 trains per hour, all of which start from or terminate at Hakata. However, it was hourly service in 1973 including rush hours, and only seven out of 19 trains a day ran between Yoshizuka and Hakata.


One of the most interesting railway in Fukuoka was Katsuta Line, a 13.8 km (8.6 miles) long rural railway between Yoshizuka and Chikuzen-Katsuta, with five stations in between.
(Yoshizuka, Mitarai, Kami-Kameyama, Shime, Shimoumi, Umi, Chikuzen-Katsuta)

It was opened in 1918 for freight trains transporting coal, but all coalfields in the area have been closed by 1964. In spite of proximity to the city centre of Fukuoka as well as construction of housing estates, JNR had never interested in passenger trains on Katsuta Line. In 1973, Yoshizuka station timetable was as follows.

 5:54  for Chikuzen-Katsuta 
 7:17  for Shime* 
 8:12  for Chikuzen-Katsuta 
 12:59  for Chikuzen-Katsuta 
 14:15  for Chikuzen-Katsuta** 
 16:29  for Chikuzen-Katsuta 
 18:57  for Chikuzen-Katsuta 
 20:29  for Chikuzen-Katsuta 
*Weekdays & Saturdays only. **Weekends & holidays only.

Local residents have been dependant on buses so that they accepted a permanent closure of the Line, which eventually took place in 1985. Had JNR provided more services or had it been succeeded by JR Kyushu, Katsuta Line would have dramatically been transformed to a major commuter rail in the city.

08 October, 2023

Second-hand Trains

Introduction

On 26 September, Seibu revealed its detailed plan to purchase and introduce second-hand trains to its branch lines. It is uncommon if not unprecedented for a major railway company to reintroduce used trains of other railway operators. What we know so far?


Background

Seibu has been known for having many environmentally unfriendly trains. A quarter of its fleets are outdated while other major private railways in the Greater Tokyo Area has mostly completed replacing old-fashioned ones. Seibu has been introducing 40000 series since 2016, but the company estimated that the replacement would not finish until 2036 at the current pace.

Therefore, Seibu concluded that reintroducing second-hand but energy-saving trains would contribute to achieve its sustainability goals by 2030, six years earlier than the initial plan. The first official announcement regarding the reintroduction was made in December 2022, and there had been various speculation about possible rolling stock since then.


Which trains to be replaced with?

101 series, 2000 series and 4000 series trains. Remaining units were built in the 1980s or early-90s, though not a few components of the 4000 series were reused from trains developed in the late-60s. The 101 series is used for Sayama and Tamagawa Lines, and the 4000 series runs Chichibu Line. The 2000 series is still widely used across the network including Ikebukuro and Shinjuku Lines. There are approximately 300 carriages in total.

There is one more train type with eco-unfriendly features called 10000 series New Red Arrow, but Seibu has not referred to its fate at all.


What trains replace them?

Odakyu 8000 series and Tokyu 9000 series trains (including Tokyu 9020 series). They are commuter trains built in the 1980s and early-90s, just as old as the Seibu trains in question. NHK reported that Seibu plans to introduce 40 and 60 carriages respectively. The Odakyu 8000 series will be for Kokubunji Line and the Tokyu 9000 series will be for Chichibu, Sayama, Tamagawa and Tamako Lines. Each unit of the 9000 series is formed of five coaches at the moment but it will be shortened to four.

According to the official document, the 8000 series will enter service in 2024 while the 9000 series will be in "2025 or after that". Many of them are likely to be compatible with driver-only operation.


Is it really a sensible idea?

Seibu had been looking for eco-friendly trains with stainless-steel bodies. Odakyu 8000 series has been its traction and motors refurbished with new ones in 2003-13, but its body is made of ordinary carbon-steel. In other words, it does not meet one of two requirements. Hence, it is not certain whether the body is durable enough for the next 10-20 years.

Tokyu 9000 series meets with both criteria though Tokyu has not classified it as environmentally friendly in the last ten years. It will run Chichibu Line which has many steep slopes and tight curves so that there should be enhanced braking systems to deal with them.

Even so, Seibu estimates that 5,700 tonnes of carbon dioxide will be reduced a year, as the second-hand trains require 50% less energy than the old trains. Needless to say, it financially help the company as well.


Wasn't there other choices?

Speculation by railway enthusiasts included JR 209 series and Tokyo Waterfront Railway 70-000 series since not a few carriages are due to be withdrawn by 2030 and they meet the two elements on Seibu's wishlist. However, the 209 series has been notorious for not being sturdy enough as JR East designed it to have half the lifespan of other trains. The 70-000 series is based on the 209 series. Probably that is why Seibu decided not to purchase them.


Are there any examples of second-hand trains?

Small private railways often use second-hand trains, but it is rare to see major railway companies purchase used trains. One of the most well-known case in Japan is Meitetsu 3880 series, which was originally Tokyu 3700 series. Introduced to Toyoko Line in 1948, the 3700 series was used by Tokyu until 1980. Meitetsu purchased all them in 1975 and 1980 to deal with skyrocketing demand. The 3880 series was mainly used on Inuyama and Kakamigahara Lines until 1985.

Since the 21st century began, there were two such cases. In 2004, JR East purchased six carriages of TWR 70-000 series, which were operational until 2022. At that time, TWR had been rearranging the series from six to ten coaches, and JR East took redundant carriages over.

The other case was Semboku Rapid Railway 3000 series, 14 carriages of which were purchased by Nanai in 2013. Nankai had to replace 7000 series trains as soon as possible but it was impractical to replace them with brand new trains. Hence, Nankai decided to reuse the 3000 series. Today, all 14 carriages are used on Nankai Main Line their car numbers unchanged.

30 September, 2023

50 years on: a comparison (part 6)...Tokyo the capital

Introduction

Commuter and suburban trains in the Greater Tokyo Area in 1973 might look quite different for some people, while those who remember the railway before Shonan-Shinjuku Line opened would not think so. Most railways in the capital have already been what we know today.

As the population in the area skyrocketed in the 1960s and 70s, trains were extremely overcrowded, with up to more than three times more passengers than maximum capacity were on a train every single day. JNR had to do something to improve "commuting hell" so that it implemented Five Directions Operation (also known as Tokyo five-direction strategy) in 1965. The seven-year project included constructions converting double-track to quadruple-track railways, making each train longer with more coaches and introducing more new trains. Not all constructions completed by 1973, but a dramatic progress had already been observed.

This article looks into five directions and inner-Tokyo, and compare them a little with the current timetables.


Chuo Main Line

Chuo Main Line was the first JNR railway to be dramatically modernised as the number of passengers had exponentially increased since the late-1950s. In 1973, commuter trains (mostly 103 series) have already been painted either orange (Rapid) or yellow (Local). Service frequency has been unchanged on both lines (though Special Rapid trains ran only at daytime in 1973).

The orange trains mostly ran between Tokyo and Takao, while the yellow trains were running between Mitaka and Chiba, both exactly as we see today. There have been through-services between Mitaka and Nishi-funabashi on Tozai Line (TRTA at that time, now Tokyo Metro) since 1969. Duration of trains were almost the same as we see today too.


Then, were not there any major difference between timetables in 1973 and 2023? There was one that may be worth noting: regional "stopping services" to and from Shinjuku in 1973. They were either loco-hauled or 115 series. There were nine services a day as shown below including one night train (though standard-class seats only).

Shinjuku (6:20) → Nagano (16:04)
Shinjuku (7:08) → Kofu (9:56)
Shinjuku (12:08) → Matsumoto (19:19)
Shinjuku (13:40) → Kofu (16:16)
Shinjuku (14:35) → Matsumoto (21:00)
Shinjuku (16:30) → Kofu (19:08)
Shinjuku (17:10) → Matsumoto (22:48)
Shinjuku (21:00) → Kofu (23:18)
Shinjuku (23:55) → Nagano (10:11)

It is also worth noting that these "stopping services" did not call at Mitaka, Kokubunji, Hino, Toyoda and Nishi-Hachioji despite "Rapid" trains stopped at all of those stations. It might have been extremely confusing for those who were not well versed in the railway.

These long-distance "stopping services" were discontinued in 1993 as Special Rapid services were extended to Otsuki.


Tohoku Main and Takasaki Lines

They were quite different from what we see today as there was no Shonan-Shinjuku and Ueno-Tokyo Lines. In 1973, all regional services were to and from Ueno. Short and middle-distance trains were provided by 115 series while long-distance ones were loco-hauled.

Most trains went as far as Utsunomiya, Kuroiso or Nikko. In addition, there were many long-distance regional services. For example, a train departing Ueno at 5:08 terminated at Koriyama (11:17), and another one leaving Ueno at 16:14 terminated at Fukushima (22:39). The longest regional train, which left Ueno at 11:17, was for Ichinoseki in Iwate Prefecture (440 km or 274 miles north of Tokyo) arriving at 23:02. However, the number of trains per se was far fewer than today, with only one or two trains per hour at daytime.

Today, regional services run only as far as Utsunomiya, but with five trains per hour at daytime. JNR had been focusing to long-distance intercity services back in 1973, but JR East adopted a different approach by running more short-distance trains. Since long-distance journeys are mostly covered by bullet trains, regional trains towards Fukushima or Miyagi are no longer needed. The current timetables must be far more convenient for local residents than those in 1973.


Joban Line

Joban Line services have been complicated for more than 50 years, but it was even worse in 1973. There had been regional "stopping services" that actually passed some small stations, Rapid trains, and Local trains calling at all stations. Regional "stopping services" were mostly 415 series while Rapid and Local trains were 103 series. In addition, some Local trains were provided by 5000 series and 6000 series from Chiyoda Line.

Regional "stopping services" included trains from Ueno to Takahagi, Taira (now Iwaki) and even Sendai. They were mostly 415 series, but two trains per day running towards Sendai were loco-hauled. Moreover, the last train of day from Ueno (23:24) to Mito (1:28) was KiHa 58 series diesel train despite the line was fully electrified. There was only one train per hour at daytime and just two trains even during rush hours. Today, three E531 series trains per hour run towards Tsuchiura or Mito at daytime.

Rapid trains between Ueno and Toride are mostly unchanged: there have been trains every 20 minutes at daytime and more during rush hours. However, there were only two services a day from Ueno to Narita via Narita Line in 1973 (both of them were coaches hauled by a diesel locomotive), while the direct train runs hourly today.

Local trains have been mostly unchanged except the through-services to Chiyoda Line. In 1973, the underground between Yoyogi-koen and Yoyogi-uehara was still under construction, hence there was no direct service to and from Odakyu line.


Sobu Main Line

Local services were almost as the same as the current timetable, though mostly provided by 103 series in 1973.

When it comes to Rapid services, frequency and duration were not so different than what we see today. 113 series trains were mostly used. The most significant difference was that Sobu Line Rapid services started from or terminated at Tokyo station, and there was no direct train to and from Yokosuka Line.

It must also be worth noting that Keiyo Line did not exist in 1973.


Tokaido Main and Yokosuka Lines

Until 1980, Tokaido Main and Yokosuka Lines shared the same tracks. Nishi-Oi, Musashi-Kosugi, Shin-Kawasaki and Higashi-Totsuka stations did not exist in 1973.

There were many Tokaido Line stopping services during rush hours. For example, six trains left Tokyo station between 5 pm and 6 pm (while there are seven trains today, excluding Ueno-Tokyo Line trains terminating at Shinagawa). However, there were only 1-4 trains per hour in the early afternoon, making it inconvenient for local residents.

Most suburban trains were for Odawara, Atami or Numazu just like we see today, but there were even longer services like Shizuoka and Hamamatsu. The longest suburban train was for Ogaki in Gifu Prefecture, leaving Tokyo at 23:35 and arriving Ogaki at 7:10. This overnight regional train was later rearranged to Moonlight Nagara and well-known among backpackers until when it was discontinued in 2020.

Meanwhile, Yokosuka Line trains seem to have been treated as less important railway than Tokaido Main Line. The 1973 timetable shows that there were only 3-4 trains per hour for most of the time, and up to just six trains from 5 pm to 6 pm. And like other JNR trains, the services were infrequent. For example, when you missed a 15:56 service at Tokyo station, you had to wait for a 16:35 service. But there was another train six minutes later.

Today, trains depart Tokyo every 15 minutes during off-peak times and there are up to eight trains per hour at peak times. You sometimes have to wait for up to 19 minutes, but still better than back in 1973.


Inner-Tokyo

Yamanote Line has been mostly unchanged since 1973 except rolling stock (103 series) and Takanawa Gateway station. However, there were some major changes in the previous year: the line was renamed from "Yamate Line" to "Yamanote Line", and de facto branch line between Ikebukuro and Akabane was separated and renamed "Akabane Line".

Akabane Line was just 5.5 km (3.4 miles) long, and eight-car 103 series ran every 5-10 minutes. Despite being short, the timetable suggests that there were many passengers between Ikebukuro and Akabane. When Saikyo Line opened in 1985, Akabane Line was incorporated to it. Today, "Akabane Line" has almost been forgotten though it is still registered as the official name.


Personal Views

Comparisons and subsequent minimal analysis show that there are a few things that were clearly different 50 years ago. Even apart from several railways that did not exist in 1973 (namely Keiyo, Saikyo, Shonan-Shinjuku and Ueno-Tokyo Lines), JNR had not implemented convenient services with frequent trains when it came to suburban rails, though commuter rails have already been similar to what we see today. The Five Directions Operation was about to be completed, but service patterns were yet to be fully modernised.

At that time, JNR had still been concentrating on long-distance trains. Such a policy was applicable not only to Express and Limited Express trains but also to regional stopping services. Such inefficient services across the country lead to a sharp decline in demand but trade unions strongly refused reforms, which eventually lead to the privatisation. JNR finally introduced completely new timetables that included short but frequent trains in November 1986, just five months before JNR became JR.

Long-distance regional stopping services sound attractive for younger generation (including me), but commuters living in suburbs of Tokyo might have felt more stressful than today. Though JR has many problems in these days, things have surely been improved in the last five decades.